For condensing's, I'm putting the 2000s and 2010s AOTY winners (including last night) into the same poll. Same as before, one pick, one vote.
2000 - Supernatural (Santana)
2001 - Two Against Nature (Steely Dan)
2002 - O Brother, Where Art Thou? Soundtrack (Various Artists)
2003 - Come Away with Me (Norah Jones)
2004 - Speakerboxxx/The Love Below (OutKast)
2005 - Genius Loves Company (Ray Charles & Various Artists)
2006 - How to Dismantle an Atomic Bomb (U2)
2007 - Taking the Long Way (Dixie Chicks)
2008 - River: The Joni Letters (Herbie Hancock)
2009 - Raising Sand (Robert Plant and Alison Krauss)
2010 - Fearless (Taylor Swift)
2011 - The Suburbs (Arcade Fire)
2012 - 21 (Adele)
2013 - Babel (Mumford & Sons)
Looking at that list above, I forgot about U2 winning their 2nd AOTY award (if a pretty questionable Grammy vote) Ah Steely Dan, best band named after a dildo ever? Again like every other AOTY poll I've done, its a random list when you look at it chronologically in retrospect.
How AD votes should be interesting.