
Originally Posted by
with_one_voice
Interesting point. Ethnically, Portman is half-Israeli, and Israel is obviously in Asia, so describing her as half-Asian is technically not incorrect. But of course, colloquially, I don't think anyone would use the adjective "Asian" to describe Israelis (especially since Israel was explicitly formed as a homeland for persecuted Jews, most of whom came from Europe). But, if one were to actually think about "what does it mean to be 'Asian'?", there is really no single answer, because of how diverse the countries of Asia are. A man who is ethnically Saudi Arabian is obviously going to look different from a man who is ethnically Russian vs one who is ethnically Chinese vs Indian. But, in the most literal sense, these are all Asians. Essentially, I think that, today, in general conversation, there's this spectrum of "Asian-ness". "East Asians" (another somewhat ambiguous term, but generally Chinese, Japanese, Korean...) seem to typically be what come to mind when someone says "Asian", followed perhaps by people from "Southeast" Asia (e.g. Thai), "South" Asia (e.g. Indian)...etc. Russians and Israelis probably come in last in this spectrum of "Asian-ness", and they themselves may not even identify as Asians (especially people from Russia, since it's partially in eastern Europe), but this doesn't necessarily mean that they are any less "Asian" than, say, a Chinese person.
(Sorry, I love discourse about geography and race.)