I do not know what you were on when you saw this, Erik; I am completely surprised but I thoroughly enjoyed it! Surely, it is not flawless at all, but it is a mighty fine musical adaptation; probably the best musical I've seen since "Everyone Says I Love You". High praise, I know!
A couple of points that I liked:
1. Russell Crowe. I am sorry, but it is a stroke of genius to cast him as Javert. His lingering anger and wounded masculinity, as well as his at times strained voice, is perfect for this character. Terrific and bold to give him this role; it helps making Javert a gritty and complicated character. So basically, everything you hated about Crowe I liked!
2. The art direction. There were times I was taken back to Gangs of New York; the sets are this gorgeous, but this never becomes one of those silly set pieces that is all about the exterior - mostly because of the cinematography. You are there with the characters in their trials and tribulations. I would strangely enough have liked to see this in 3D.
3. Hugh Jackman. This is a threat for the Oscar win - I am sorry, but if they are hesitant to give DDL a third Oscar at 55, they will give it to Jackman instead. Crowdpleasing and saintly if I ever saw it. Jackman was made for this part.
I did not like Hathaway very much - I mean, she's very effective but she came across a bit too calculated for me. Seyfried and Redmayne were good and Barks was fine too, but I would not nominate them for anything.
Truly - and you are going to hate me for it - the champion of this film is Hooper. This is very much a director's movie. I would not be too surprised to see him take that fifth slot in BD. Brava!
