Originally Posted by McTeague
Are you really going to compare PSH in Boogie nights, to PSH in Capote, to PSH in Charlie Wilson's War, to PSH in The Master? Really? The only role "similar" to Lancaster Dodd is the one in "Doubt", but even that is different from Lancaster Dodd.
Updated with ZDT and Seven Psychopaths.
Last edited by Shy_Hallaman; 01-24-2013 at 03:59 PM.
I recently rewatched Beasts, Les Mis and Moonrise. UGH...I love my top five SOOOO MUCH...and yes, Beasts and Moonrise are now top tier for me
This. I see where people who criticize Hoffman's acting style come from sometimes (he can get hammy, overly theatrical) but there's no denying that he has played a wide variety of characters, and played them differently, throughout his career.
Are you really going to compare PSH in Boogie nights, to PSH in Capote, to PSH in Charlie Wilson's War, to PSH in The Master? Really? The only role "similar" to Lancaster Dodd is the one in "Doubt", but even that is different from Lancaster Dodd.
I personally think that Hoffman is one of the finest working actors right now
Honestly, even in overly hammy mode he's great fun to watch.I personally think that Hoffman is one of the finest working actors right now
I post my ballot again because I changed just about anything in it.
BEST ACTOR
Jack Black - BERNIE
Bogdan Dumitrache - BEST INTENTIONS
Denis Lavant - HOLY MOTORS
Matthew McConaughey - KILLER JOE
Milan Peschel - STOPPED ON TRACK
Joaquin Phoenix - THE MASTER
BEST ACTRESS
Kirsten Dunst - BACHELORETTE
Francisca Gavilan - VIOLETA
Nina Hoss - BARBARA
Aggeliki Papoulia - ALPS
Emmanuelle Riva - AMOUR
Andrea Riseborough - SHADOW DANCER
BEST SUPPORTING ACTOR
Anton Adasinsky - FAUST
Dwight Henry - BEASTS OF THE SOUTHERN WILD
Philip Seymour Hoffman - THE MASTER
Scoot McNairy - KILLING THEM SOFTLY
Krzysztof Stroinski - FEAR OF FALLING
Christopher Walken - A LATE QUARTET
BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS
Blythe Danner - HELLO I MUST BE GOING
Eugene Domingo - WOMAN IN A SEPTIC TANK
Ann Dowd - COMPLIANCE
Helene Florent - CAFE DE FLORE
Gina Gershon - KILLER JOE
Lea Seydoux - SISTER
BEST ORIGINAL SCORE
Bruno Coulais - FAREWELL, MY QUEEN
Alexandre Desplat - MOONRISE KINGDOM
Jonny Greenwood - THE MASTER
Reinhold Heil, Johnny Klimek, Tom Tykwer - CLOUD ATLAS
Dan Romer, Benh Zeiltin - BEASTS OF THE SOUTHERN WILD
Gustavo Santaolalla - ON THE ROAD
BEST CINEMATOGRAPHY
Marius Dybwad Brandrud - PLAY
Matyas Erdely - MISS BALA
Mihai Malaimare Jr. - THE MASTER
Seamus McGarvey - ANNA KARENINA
Rui Pocas - TABU
Robert D. Yeoman - MOONRISE KINGDOM
BEST ADAPTED SCREENPLAY
Andrew Dominik - KILLING THEM SOFTLY
Benoit Jacquot, Gilles Taurand - FAREWELL, MY QUEEN
Tony Kushner - LINCOLN
Jaroslav Rudik, Jaroslav Svejdik - ALOIS NEBEL
Joachim Trier, Eskil Vogt - OSLO, 31. AUGUST
Benh Zeitlin, Lucy Alibar - BEASTS OF THE SOUTHERN WILD
BEST ORIGINAL SCREENPLAY
Paul Thomas Anderson - THE MASTER
Wes Anderson, Roman Coppola - MOONRISE KINGDOM
Sang-soo Hong - THE DAY HE ARRIVES
Michael Haneke - AMOUR
Martin McDonagh - SEVEN PSYCHOPATHS
Whit Stillman - DAMSELS IN DISTRESS
BEST EDITING
Chris Dickens - BERBERIAN SOUND STUDIO
Bettina Bohler - BARBARA
Nejc Gazvoda, Janez Lapajne - A TRIP
Olivier Bugge Coute, Gisle Tveito - OSLO, 31. AUGUST
Wojciech Mrówczyński - MANHUNT
Andrew Weisblum - MOONRISE KINGDOM
BEST DOCUMENTARY
AI WEIWEI: NEVER SORRY
JIRO DREAMS OF SUSHI
SEARCHING FOR SUGAR MAN
SIDE BY SIDE
THE IMPOSTER
THIS IS NOT A FILM
BEST ORIGINAL SONG
"Bend with Me" from WISH YOU WERE HERE
"Dull Tool" from THIS IS 40
Everybody Needs a Best Friend from TED
"Freedom" from DJANGO UNCHAINED
"Nobody to Love" from END OF WATCH
"Cosmonaut" from LAWLESS
BEST DIRECTING
Nuri Bilge Ceylan - ONCE UPON A TIME IN ANATOLIA
Leos Carax - HOLY MOTORS
Miguel Gomes - TABU
David O. Russell - SILVER LININGS PLAYBOOK
Peter Strickland - BERBERIAN SOUND STUDIO
Joachim Trier - OSLO, 31. AUGUST
BEST ANIMATED FILM
ALOIS NEBEL
FRANKENWEENIE
PARANORMAN
THE PAINTING
THE PIRATES! BAND OF MISFITS
WRECK-IT-RALPH
BEST FILM
1 AMOUR
2 THE MASTER
3 ONCE UPON A TIME IN ANATOLIA
4 BERBERIAN SOUND STUDIO
5 MOONRISE KINGDOM
6 OSLO, 31. AUGUST
7 TABU
8 HOLY MOTORS
9 DJANGO UNCHAINED
10 KILLER JOE
11 BEASTS OF THE SOUTHERN WILD
12 KILLING THEM SOFTLY
13 MISS BALA
14 FAUST
15 OBŁAWA
16 SILVER LININGS PLAYBOOK
17 PARADISE: LOVE
18 LOOPER
19 SKYFALL
20 ZERO DARK THIRTY
I just finished watching it. Fucking BRILLIANT
No...Lincoln...anywhere?
Haven't seen it yet. Amour, Django, Life of Pi either.
But after seeing 60+ films from 2012, I thought it was time to post the winners already.
This seems really bizarre to me. Like, you've been champaining Lincoln like it was the second coming for months and demeaning all who talked against it and then, the day after the Oscars, you reveal you haven't seen it and are actually going to announce your winners before you do?
Yeah... So?
Finally saw The Master
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
